If your home appraisal comes in lower than the agreed-upon sale price, you are not without recourse. Challenging a low appraisal is a standard industry practice that can save a transaction. Based on our experience assessment, success hinges on providing specific, data-driven evidence to the lender, such as errors in the report or superior comparable sales (comps). This guide outlines the common reasons for a low valuation and the concrete steps you can take to dispute it effectively.
Why Did My Home Appraise for Less Than the Sale Price?
A lower-than-expected appraisal can stem from several factors, often related to shifting market conditions and property-specific details.
- Market Volatility: "Market shifts like those we've experienced over the last few years can significantly impact home values," notes David Schulz, a broker in Naples, Florida. In a rapidly appreciating market, appraisals based on sales from 60-90 days ago may not reflect current buyer demand.
- Property Condition and Features: The appraiser evaluates your home against recently sold properties in your area. A lack of modern upgrades or amenities like a pool, updated kitchen, or hurricane-impact windows can result in a lower valuation compared to better-equipped comparable sales.
- Overpaying During a Peak: If you purchased the home at the peak of a hot market, perhaps during a bidding war, the current appraisal might simply reflect a more normalized market value. "When the market is hot, it isn’t uncommon to see appraisals that are lower than the sales price," explains Omer Reiner, a real estate agent.
- Appraiser's Local Knowledge: Appraisers are licensed professionals hired by the lender to provide a neutral valuation. However, if the appraiser is not intimately familiar with your specific neighborhood or fails to account for hyper-local trends, undervaluation can occur.
How Can I Challenge a Low Appraisal Result?
Formally disputing an appraisal is known as submitting a Reconsideration of Value (ROV). The burden of proof is on you, the seller, to provide compelling evidence. The process generally involves these steps:
- Review the Appraisal Report for Errors: Carefully examine the report for any factual inaccuracies. This includes incorrect square footage, bedroom/bathroom count, or lot size. Also, check if the appraiser used comps from a less desirable neighborhood or failed to account for significant home improvements.
- Gather Superior Comparable Sales: Work with your real estate agent to identify 3-5 recent sales that better support your home’s value. These should be homes as similar to yours as possible, sold within the last three months, and ideally located closer to your property than those used in the original appraisal.
- Compile a Formal Appeal Package: This should be a professional document sent to your lender (who then forwards it to the appraiser). Include:
- A cover letter politely pointing out the discrepancies.
- A list of the factual errors found.
- Data sheets and photos of your superior comparable sales.
- Receipts and photos of any major upgrades (e.g., a new roof, HVAC system, or kitchen renovation).
What Is the Likelihood of a Successful Appraisal Dispute?
The outcome of an appraisal dispute is not guaranteed. "The process may delay closing and does not guarantee that the appraisal will be adjusted," cautions Schulz. However, it is often a worthwhile effort, especially if you have clear, objective evidence. The appraiser is only obligated to consider your submission; they are not required to change their valuation. The likelihood of success increases significantly with a strong, data-backed case prepared by an experienced real estate agent.
The key to navigating a low appraisal is preparation and a pragmatic approach. While challenging the value is a viable option, sellers should also be prepared to negotiate with the buyer on the price difference or consider other alternatives if the dispute is unsuccessful. A successful challenge relies almost entirely on providing objective data, not subjective opinions about your home's worth.
Share
