Share

While a significant U.S. housing market downturn is predicted for 2023, the vast majority of recent homebuyers are insulated from the immediate risk of an underwater mortgage. According to a Redfin analysis, only 3.4% of homeowners who purchased in the last two years would owe more than their home is worth if prices fall by 4% this year. This is primarily due to the substantial equity gained during the pandemic-era price surge. However, risk is not evenly distributed, with homeowners in specific metropolitan areas facing a higher probability of negative equity.
An underwater mortgage, also known as being "upside-down," occurs when the outstanding loan balance on a home exceeds the property's current market value. This situation can arise when home prices fall significantly after purchase. For example, if you bought a home for $400,000 with a $380,000 mortgage and its value drops to $350,000, you would be underwater by $30,000.
Homeowners who bought between January 2021 and September 2022 are generally well-positioned for several key reasons:
Based on our experience assessment, even if prices fall by 8%—double the expected decline—only 6.3% of new homeowners would be underwater. It would require a drop of roughly 12% for the share of underwater homeowners to reach double digits, a scenario economists consider highly unlikely.
The analysis identifies that risk is concentrated in specific types of markets: popular pandemic migration destinations and expensive West Coast tech hubs. The following table illustrates the metros with the highest risk if prices fall 4%.
| Metropolitan Area | % of Recent Buyers at Risk (4% Price Drop) |
|---|---|
| Sacramento, CA | 9.0% |
| Phoenix, AZ | 7.3% |
| Virginia Beach, VA | 7.3% |
| Oakland, CA | 6.6% |
| Seattle, WA | 6.4% |
These areas saw some of the most dramatic price increases in the country, often exceeding 30%, making them more susceptible to a correction. Factors like a high concentration of remote workers, tech industry layoffs, and the use of specialized loans with low down payments contribute to the elevated risk.
In contrast, several Florida markets demonstrate remarkable resilience. If home prices drop 4% in 2023, less than 0.5% of recent buyers in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and West Palm Beach would be underwater. In these metros, strong demand from remote workers and retirees relocating from more expensive parts of the country continues to support robust price growth, which is still in the double digits year-over-year.
A widespread foreclosure crisis akin to the 2008 Great Recession is highly improbable. Most homeowners have significant equity cushions, allowing them to sell their homes instead of facing foreclosure if they encounter financial hardship. Furthermore, any potential recession in 2023 is projected to be mild, with limited job losses.
For most homeowners, a decline in home value represents a temporary paper loss, not a permanent one, provided they do not need to sell in the near term. Historical trends suggest that property values are likely to recover once mortgage rates decrease and the economy stabilizes.
The key takeaway is that location is the critical factor determining risk. While the national outlook for recent homebuyers is strong, those in cooling boomtowns should be aware of their local market conditions. Having substantial equity provides a crucial buffer and options if your financial situation changes. For all homeowners, staying informed about your local real estate trends is the best strategy for navigating the 2023 market shift.









