Browse
Log in / Register
Share
For homeowners, the decision is no longer if to get a security system, but which type best fits their needs and budget. The core choice is between professionally monitored traditional systems and self-monitored DIY options. The best system depends on your budget, desired level of protection, and technical comfort. Traditional systems offer 24/7 professional monitoring and reliability during outages but come with higher upfront costs and potential long-term contracts. DIY systems provide flexibility, lower initial investment, and smart home integration but place the responsibility of monitoring solely on the homeowner.
The most significant difference lies in monitoring. A professionally monitored system includes 24/7 surveillance by a team of experts. When an alarm is triggered—whether from a security camera, motion sensor, or carbon monoxide detector—the monitoring center attempts to contact you and can dispatch emergency services if you are unreachable.
In contrast, a self-monitored DIY system relies on you. You receive alerts directly to your smartphone. The critical drawback is the absence of a safety net if you miss an alert due to a dead battery, being in a meeting, or having your phone on Do Not Disturb. Based on our experience assessment, professional monitoring provides a crucial layer of security for those who are often away from home or desire maximum peace of mind.
The financial investment varies dramatically between the two paths. A basic DIY setup with self-monitoring can cost around $200 for equipment if you install it yourself. Traditional systems, however, often involve significant setup and equipment fees, which can be upward of $2,000 for a comprehensive system, plus a monthly monitoring charge typically ranging from $20 to $40.
It's important to look beyond the sticker price. Some DIY companies charge monthly fees for advanced app features, and equipment additions can quickly increase the total cost. Conversely, some traditional providers offer financing options that bundle equipment costs into the monthly fee, softening the initial financial blow.
| System Type | Typical Upfront Cost | Monthly Monitoring Fee | Contract Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Professional | $500 - $2,000+ | $20 - $40+ | Often (1-3 years) |
| DIY Self-Monitored | ~$200+ | $0 (or minimal for app access) | Rarely |
Yes, installing a security system can lead to discounts on your homeowners insurance premiums. The amount saved varies by provider but is often based on the system's features. Fully monitored systems typically qualify for the highest discounts, sometimes up to 15%. On average, savings are around 5%, which translates to approximately $59 annually according to industry analyses.
Some traditional security companies enhance this value with a burglary guarantee, agreeing to pay your insurance deductible (or a portion of it) if a burglary occurs while the system is armed. This combination of premium discounts and financial guarantees can partially offset the higher cost of a professional system over time.
A key advantage of traditional systems is cellular failover. This means the base station uses a cellular connection as a backup, ensuring the system remains online and can communicate with the monitoring center even during a power outage or Wi-Fi failure. Most DIY systems are solely dependent on your home’s internet connection.
Regarding technology, the line is blurring. Modern buyers often prefer systems that integrate with smart home devices. While DIY brands like Ring and Nest are known for this, traditional companies have partnerships with tech giants like Google, allowing their systems to work seamlessly with devices like Nest Cams, smart doorbells, and displays. The choice is no longer between "smart" and "dumb" systems, but between different ecosystems.
To make the right decision for your home, weigh these factors carefully:
