Browse
Log in / Register
Share
For homeowners considering selling their current property to buy a more expensive one, waiting for home values to increase is typically a flawed strategy. While your home's value may rise, the price of the next home will likely increase even more. The more significant financial risk, however, comes from potential interest rate hikes. Trading a low-interest-rate mortgage for a new loan at a higher rate can drastically increase your monthly payment and long-term costs, often outweighing any gains from appreciated equity.
A "move-up buyer" is a current homeowner who sells their property to purchase a more expensive or desirable home. The common assumption is that if you wait, your home will be worth more, giving you a larger down payment for your next purchase. However, this ignores the market dynamics of the "move-up" price segment. In a rising market, the percentage increase on a higher-priced home represents a greater absolute dollar amount than the same percentage increase on a lower-priced one.
For example, if your $400,000 home appreciates by 5%, it gains $20,000 in value. If the $600,000 home you want appreciates by the same 5%, it increases by $30,000. By waiting, you now need an additional $10,000 to bridge the new price gap. The goal is to build equity, but the cost of the upgrade grows faster than the equity in your current home.
The most substantial financial risk for move-up buyers is not just price appreciation, but the prospect of higher mortgage rates. Many current homeowners have mortgages with historically low interest rates, some below 4% or even 3%. If you sell your home, you relinquish that loan. Your new mortgage for the next property will be based on prevailing rates at the time of purchase.
Most economists project that rates will eventually trend toward historical norms, which are well above 5%. Even a modest increase can have a profound effect on your monthly housing expense. The table below illustrates the impact of a higher interest rate on a $500,000, 30-year fixed-rate mortgage.
| Loan Amount | Interest Rate | Monthly Principal & Interest | Total Interest Paid Over Loan Life |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500,000 | 4.0% | $2,387 | $359,348 |
| $500,000 | 6.0% | $2,998 | $579,191 |
| Difference | +2.0% | +$611/month | +$219,843 |
As shown, a 2% rate increase adds over $600 to your monthly payment and more than $200,000 in total interest. This increased cost can easily erase the financial benefit gained from your previous home's appreciation.
The decision to become a move-up buyer should not be based solely on market timing. Based on our experience assessment, a move may be justified for lifestyle reasons that outweigh purely financial considerations, such as needing more space for a growing family, a job relocation, or a strong desire for a different location or type of home. The key is to run the numbers carefully with a mortgage calculator and realistic estimates for your current home's sale price and the next home's purchase price, factoring in various interest rate scenarios.
The optimal time to be a move-up buyer is often during a period of stable or slightly declining interest rates, even if home prices are still rising. Locking in a favorable mortgage rate is frequently more valuable than trying to time the peak of the market for your sale.
Before deciding to wait for the market, conduct a thorough financial analysis. Calculate the new monthly payment you would face at a higher interest rate to understand the true cost of waiting. Focus on your long-term housing needs rather than short-term market predictions. If you find a home that perfectly suits your family's needs for the foreseeable future, moving now with a solid financial plan may be a wiser choice than gambling on future market conditions. Ultimately, the goal is to upgrade your lifestyle without jeopardizing your financial stability.
