Browse
Log in / Register
Share
A Nantucket property owner faces a lawsuit seeking over $1.4 million in damages after allegedly cutting down 16 of his neighbor's mature trees to improve his ocean view, a stark reminder of the severe legal and financial consequences of violating property lines. This case underscores a critical principle for homeowners: altering a neighbor's property without explicit permission constitutes trespassing and can lead to substantial liability. Understanding property boundaries and obtaining written agreements before any landscaping work near a lot line is essential to avoid costly litigation.
The core allegation in the Nantucket lawsuit is trespassing, which occurs when someone intentionally enters another person's property without permission. The lawsuit further claims the action was "calculated" and done with "full knowledge that he lacked any legal right." Beyond trespassing, removing trees without authorization can lead to claims for timber trespass. In such cases, damages are not based merely on the cost of the trees but on the diminished value they caused to the property. The plaintiff is seeking compensation for the lasting damage to the "character, value, and privacy of the property," with mature, decades-old trees like the cedar, cherry, and Leyland Cypresses that were removed often carrying significant replacement value.
Mature trees contribute significantly to a property's value, often acting as a natural buffer that provides privacy, reduces noise, and enhances curb appeal. Their removal can lead to property value diminution, meaning the property is worth less after the action. In this case, the lost trees, some over 30 feet high and planted in the 1970s, served as a visual and sound barrier between the home and a nearby road and pond. The lawsuit alleges their loss "significantly diminished the value and character" of the plaintiff's land. For homeowners, this highlights that a neighbor's action, even if it improves their own view, can legally be considered damaging to adjacent property values.
If a neighbor alters your property without consent, based on our experience assessment, a structured approach is recommended. First, document the damage thoroughly with photographs and videos. Second, contact local law enforcement to file a report, which creates an official record—as was done in this case. Third, obtain a professional appraisal to quantify the financial impact on your property's value. Finally, consult with a real estate attorney to understand your rights and the potential for recovering damages through a civil lawsuit, which is the step the plaintiff has taken in this dispute.
To prevent such disputes, always verify your property lines with a recent survey before beginning any landscaping project near the edge of your lot. For any work that could affect a neighbor's land, securing a written agreement is the most effective way to avoid legal conflict and protect your financial interests.
