Is the Kia EV6 a Better Value Than the Tesla Model Y?

Based on our assessment experience, the 2022 Kia EV6 emerges as a more compelling overall value than the 2021 Tesla Model Y, despite the Tesla's brand cachet and superior home-charging speed. The EV6's decisive victory in DC fast charging, more comfortable ride, and lower price point outweigh the Model Y's advantages in cargo space and sporty handling for many buyers.

The electric SUV market is no longer a one-horse race. While the Tesla Model Y has long been the benchmark, the all-new Kia EV6 presents a formidable challenge. This head-to-head comparison, based on extensive testing of charging, efficiency, acceleration, and daily usability, reveals a winner that might surprise you. The core question isn't just about performance, but value: does the Tesla Model Y justify a price tag that can be over $16,000 higher than a similarly equipped Kia EV6?

How Did We Test These Electric SUVs?

To ensure an objective and verifiable comparison, we subjected both vehicles to a rigorous testing regimen. This included a 215-mile highway route to measure real-world efficiency and range accuracy, visits to a drag strip for 0-60 mph and quarter-mile acceleration tests, and a handling course to evaluate dynamics. Crucially, we tested both home charging and DC fast-charging capabilities, which account for a significant portion of the overall score. The results were closer than expected, with the final scores coming in at 456 for the Kia EV6 and 446 for the Tesla Model Y.

The table below summarizes the key objective data from our testing.

Where Did the Kia EV6 Excel?

The Kia EV6's victory was built on its superior value proposition and performance in several key areas that impact daily ownership.

What makes the Kia EV6's fast charging so impressive? The most significant advantage for the EV6 was its blistering DC fast-charging speed. Utilizing its advanced 800-volt architecture (a system that allows for much faster charging than the more common 400-volt systems), the EV6 added 162 miles of range in just 18 minutes. The Tesla Model Y, despite starting at a higher peak charging rate, took 28 minutes to add a similar 164 miles of range. This means the EV6 charged at an average rate of 9 miles of range per minute, dwarfing the Model Y's 5.9 miles per minute. For road trips, this time savings is a substantial benefit.

Is the Kia EV6 more comfortable for daily driving? Absolutely. The EV6's ride quality is notably more comfortable than the Model Y's firm, often harsh ride. The cabin is also significantly quieter, with better isolation from road and tire noise. Furthermore, the EV6 features a more traditional and intuitive user interface with a digital instrument cluster directly in front of the driver, avoiding the Model Y's polarizing reliance on a central touchscreen for all controls, including the speedometer. The EV6 also includes valuable features like a vehicle-to-load (V2L) power outlet at no extra cost, allowing you to power electronic devices from the car's battery.

Where Does the Tesla Model Y Still Hold an Advantage?

The Tesla Model Y remains a strong contender with best-in-class capabilities in specific areas that may be critical for some buyers.

Does the Tesla Model Y offer better performance? While the EV6 was slightly quicker to 60 mph, the Model Y feels more potent at higher speeds. Its quarter-mile acceleration time of 12.77 seconds at 114.35 mph was notably better than the EV6's 13.25 seconds at 102.21 mph. This translates to more confident passing power on the highway. The Model Y also excels in handling and driving engagement, with sharper, more sports-car-like reflexes that make it more entertaining on a winding road.

How much more practical is the Tesla Model Y? The Model Y's larger dimensions translate into a clear advantage in cargo space. We measured 32% more cargo capacity behind the second row compared to the EV6. Its front trunk (frunk) is also substantially larger and more usable. The Model Y also has a superior home-charging speed, adding 46 miles of range per hour versus the EV6's 33 miles, which is beneficial for owners who primarily charge overnight at home. Tesla's trip-planning software is also more advanced, automatically routing you through Supercharger stations if needed.

Which Electric SUV Is the Right Choice for You?

The choice between these two excellent electric SUVs ultimately comes down to your priorities and budget.

• Choose the Kia EV6 if: Your priority is overall value, rapid public charging, and daily comfort. The EV6 wins on price, ride quality, and fast-charging speed, making it an incredibly smart and rational choice for most buyers.
• Choose the Tesla Model Y if: You prioritize sporty driving dynamics, maximum cargo space, and the convenience of Tesla's Supercharger network. If you have easy access to home charging and value a more engaging drive, the Model Y remains a compelling option, though its higher price is harder to justify.

In conclusion, based on our comprehensive testing, the Kia EV6 presents a more balanced and financially sensible package. It challenges the established hierarchy by proving that a lower price does not mean lower performance, ultimately offering a better blend of cutting-edge charging technology, comfort, and value for the money.