Providing an effective job reference requires a structured approach focused on presenting a candidate's strengths honestly and concurately. A strong reference can be a deciding factor in a competitive hiring process, offering a third-party validation of a candidate's skills and character. Based on our assessment experience, references that are specific, prepared, and aligned with the job description significantly increase a candidate's chances of receiving an offer.
What is a Reference and Why is it Important for a Job Application?
A reference is the contact information for an individual who can verify a job applicant's professional claims, skills, and character. Employers use references as part of the candidate screening process to confirm details on a CV and assess cultural fit. According to a survey by SHRM (Society for Human Resource Management), over 80% of employers conduct reference checks. A compelling reference provides crucial insight beyond the interview, helping an employer choose between similarly qualified candidates by offering a credible, external perspective on performance and work ethic.
What Are the Different Types of References You May Be Asked to Provide?
Understanding the type of reference required is the first step to providing relevant information. Employers typically request one of two types:
- Professional Reference: This comes from someone who has supervised, managed, or worked directly with the candidate. The goal is to confirm professional experience, technical skills, and workplace behavior. A hiring manager might ask about the applicant's problem-solving abilities, reliability, and key achievements. Most employers expect at least one professional reference.
- Character Reference: This is provided by someone who knows the candidate well personally, such as a mentor, professor, or community leader, but not necessarily in a professional capacity. It focuses on personal attributes like integrity, adaptability, and values. This type is particularly valuable for entry-level candidates or those re-entering the workforce.
How Can You Prepare to Give an Effective Reference?
Preparation ensures your reference is both positive and substantive. Follow these steps to get ready:
- Confirm the Details. Ask the candidate whether they need a professional or character reference and for which specific role. Request a copy of the job description and their updated CV. This helps you tailor your feedback to the position's requirements.
- Gather Specific Examples. Think of concrete instances that demonstrate the candidate's skills. Instead of saying "they are a good leader," describe a project they successfully led and the positive outcome. This adds credibility and impact.
- Anticipate Common Questions. Employers often use a structured interview format for reference checks. Prepare notes for questions like:
- "What was your professional relationship with the candidate?"
- "What are their greatest strengths and areas for development?"
- "Would you rehire this person?"
What is the Best Way to Structure Your Feedback During a Reference Check?
Whether the check is conducted via phone, video call, or a written letter, clarity and honesty are paramount.
- For Verbal References: Answer questions directly and concisely. Use a positive tone and support your statements with the examples you prepared. If asked about a weakness, frame it constructively, such as, "They are highly detail-oriented, and we found that using project management software helped them delegate tasks more effectively."
- For Written References (Letters of Recommendation): Use a formal business letter format. Include your relationship to the candidate, the duration of your association, and specific accolades. Highlight 2-3 key skills relevant to the job and conclude with a strong, unequivocal recommendation.
What Should You Avoid When Giving a Reference?
Maintain your credibility by avoiding these common pitfalls:
- Do not exaggerate or misrepresent the candidate's abilities. This can harm their reputation and your own.
- Avoid vague generalities. Phrases like "hard worker" are less impactful than specific achievements.
- Do not volunteer negative information unprompted. If asked, provide balanced, factual feedback.
To provide a reference that truly makes a difference, focus on preparation, specificity, and honesty. By aligning your feedback with the job's needs and providing verifiable examples, you offer an employer valuable insight that can confidently tip the scales in the candidate's favor.
Share
