Redfin's "Best Places to Live" ranking provides an objective evaluation of metro areas across the U.S. by scoring them across four critical categories: Community and Health, Navigability, Housing and Economy, and Recreation and Leisure. The methodology uses a weighted system comprising 20 distinct factors to generate a final score, ensuring a balanced assessment of quality of life. To ensure fairness between states of different sizes, population thresholds are applied, preventing larger metros from having an automatic advantage. This article breaks down the complete methodology behind the rankings.
What Criteria Are Used to Rank the Best Places to Live?
The overall score for each metropolitan area is derived from a proprietary model that aggregates 20 data points. These points are grouped into four umbrella categories, each assigned a specific weight to reflect its importance to overall livability.
- Community and Health (40% Weight): This category assesses a metro's ability to serve its residents through essential services and amenities. It is considered the most significant factor, accounting for 40% of the total score.
- Navigability (20% Weight): This measures the ease of moving around a metro area, considering commute times and transportation infrastructure.
- Housing and Economy (20% Weight): This evaluates the strength of the local housing market and economic conditions, which are vital for financial stability.
- Recreation and Leisure (20% Weight): This scores the availability of social, dining, and entertainment options that contribute to a well-rounded lifestyle.
How Does the Community and Health Category Break Down?
Accounting for the largest share of the score, the Community and Health category is broken down into four components:
- Health and Medicine (17%): This factor counts essential healthcare amenities, including hospitals, dental and physician offices, mental health services, and veterinary clinics.
- Landmarks and Outdoors (12%): This measures access to open outdoor spaces like parks, beaches, forests, and protected historic sites.
- Community and Government (8%): This includes public amenities such as post offices, courthouses, schools, universities, and community centers.
- Share of Homes that Use Solar Energy (3%): This data point measures the percentage of homes using solar panels, which benefits both the environment and household utility costs.
What Factors Determine an Area’s Navigability?
The Navigability score is determined by how easily residents can get around, with a focus on reducing commute stress. The specific factors are:
- Average Commuting Time (7%): The methodology favors shorter average commute times.
- Travel and Transportation (5%): This counts amenities like airports, train stations, major highways, and gas stations.
- Walk Score (3%), Transit Score (3%), and Bike Score (2%): These standardized scores measure the walkability, public transit access, and bike-friendliness of a metro area's center.
What Defines the Housing and Economy Score?
This category balances housing market activity with key economic indicators. The components include:
- Median Home Sale Price (7%): To promote affordability, the model favors a lower median sale price.
- Share of Residents Who Are Unemployed (4%): A lower unemployment rate is favored.
- Share of Residents with a High School Diploma (3%): This measures the percentage of residents whose highest education level is a high school diploma.
- Estimated Per-capita Income (3%): This figure, which divides the total area income by its population, is favored to be higher.
- Median Number of Days a Home Stays on the Market (2%): A lower number indicates a more active housing market and is favored.
- Share of Homes Sold Above List Price (1%): A higher percentage suggests strong buyer demand.
How Is Recreation and Leisure Measured?
This category evaluates the opportunities for socialization and relaxation, which are shown to improve quality of life. It is broken down as follows:
- Food and Drink (7%): This counts the number of restaurants, bars, breweries, and cafes.
- Arts and Entertainment (4%): This includes venues like museums, zoos, comedy clubs, and performing arts centers.
- Sports and Recreation (3%): This measures the availability of gyms, sports venues, golf courses, and studios.
- Retail (3%): This factor counts all types of retail stores, from groceries to pharmacies to fashion outlets.
- Events (3%): This includes festivals, fairs, markets, and conventions.
To ensure a fair comparison across all 50 states, Redfin's methodology applies population thresholds. For example, metros in states with over 20 million residents must have a population of at least 100,000 to be considered, while smaller states have lower thresholds. The data is sourced from reputable providers like the Census Bureau API, Redfin's own housing data, and location APIs like Foursquare and Google Places. Each data point is normalized to a 0-100 scale, multiplied by its assigned weight, and summed to create a final, comparable score for each metro area.
Based on our experience assessment, understanding the factors behind these rankings can help you identify metros that align with your priorities, whether that's healthcare access, a short commute, or an affordable housing market. The comprehensive methodology aims to provide a data-driven starting point for your home search.
Share
