Browse
Log in / Register
Share
An HOA violation for brown grass and a dented garage led to a Florida homeowner's arrest and week-long jail sentence, highlighting how quickly disputes with a Homeowners Association (HOA) can escalate. This extreme case underscores a critical lesson for the over 74 million Americans living in community associations: understanding your rights and the HOA's enforcement power is essential to avoid legal consequences. The most effective strategy is often early, proactive communication to resolve issues before they spiral into lawsuits and liens against your property.
The situation for homeowner Irena Green began with routine citations for minor violations but intensified after she ignored a formal mediation request from the HOA. The association subsequently filed a lawsuit. When Green, representing herself, missed a court date—claiming she never received notification—the judge issued a bench warrant for her arrest. This illustrates that while HOAs are civil entities, their legal actions can intersect with the court system. Failure to respond to a court order, even one stemming from an HOA dispute, can result in a judge issuing an arrest warrant for contempt of court.
This case is not an isolated incident. According to real estate attorney Bruce Ailion, "The last several years have seen significant abuses. It seems like almost every day, I am contacted by someone with a very serious situation with their HOA." Industry consolidation among management companies has sometimes led to a decline in service quality, creating an environment where disputes can fester.
The financial stakes in an HOA dispute are high and can quickly become unmanageable. Most HOA governing documents explicitly outline fees for violations, along with interest, late charges, and collection costs.
| HOA Fee Component | Potential Impact |
|---|---|
| Initial Fine (e.g., $50/day) | The starting point for a violation. |
| Late Fees & Interest | Can cause the total debt to grow exponentially. |
| Attorney's Fees (HOA's) | Often charged to the homeowner if the HOA prevails. |
| Total Lien Amount | A lien is placed on the property, preventing sale or refinancing until paid. |
“What might have started out as a $50 per day charge can quickly grow to the thousands or tens of thousands of dollars if the homeowner decides to fight on principle versus comply,” explains Ailion. These liens are secured against your property, and title insurance will typically not be issued during a sale until all past-due charges are settled, meaning you cannot sell your home without resolving the debt.
The overwhelming advice from legal experts is to seek an amicable resolution from the very beginning. Open a line of communication with the HOA board or property manager immediately upon receiving a violation notice. David Kim, an association attorney in Florida, advises, "Effective communication to understand the reasoning behind the HOA's position can help to prevent further escalation."
Attempting to ignore the problem is the riskiest approach. HOAs are required to send notices, often via certified mail, to the owner's address of record. As attorney Jonharold Cicero notes, "It’s odd when a homeowner suddenly states they no longer receive any community communications." Tenants collecting your mail or a vacant property are not valid excuses for missing official notices in the eyes of the court.
If your initial efforts at communication fail, consult with a local real estate attorney before the situation worsens. They can provide guidance on your specific rights and help negotiate a settlement. However, as Ailion cautions, litigation is seldom the best solution for the homeowner, who is often at a significant disadvantage and may be responsible for both their own and the HOA's legal fees.
The most practical advice for homeowners is to address violations promptly. While enforcing rules is critical, many HOAs are willing to allow a reasonable amount of time to correct a violation if the homeowner communicates cooperatively. As Bruce Ailion notes, "If you can’t be compliant, owning in an HOA may not be for you." The intended benefits of an HOA—maintained property values and community standards—come with the responsibility to adhere to its governing documents.
