Share

The transformation of struggling shopping malls into vibrant, mixed-use communities is emerging as a powerful solution to America's persistent housing shortage. By repurposing underutilized retail spaces, particularly the large footprints left by anchor stores like Sears and JCPenney, developers can quickly add housing supply to high-demand suburban corridors. This trend, gaining momentum from New Jersey to Colorado, leverages existing infrastructure to create walkable neighborhoods, offering a sustainable alternative to urban sprawl. The key advantage is speed: utilizing existing infrastructure can bring homes to the market more quickly than traditional ground-up development.
The shift is primarily driven by two converging factors: the decline of traditional retail and a critical national housing shortage. As e-commerce grows, aging malls have become financially unsustainable. Simultaneously, suburban areas near major employment hubs face intense pressure to increase housing density. Repurposing mall sites, which are often already located along major commuter routes with existing road and utility access, presents a logical solution. Hannah Jones, a senior economic research analyst, notes this "shift from retail to residential is a logical solution in a country facing a persistent housing shortage," avoiding the delays of greenfield development.
A prime example is the HiFi project in Broomfield, Colorado, adjacent to the FlatIron Crossing mall. This 25-acre development goes beyond simple housing, creating a true mixed-use community—a planning term for an area that combines residential, commercial, and recreational spaces. The project will add 347 multifamily residences, 90,000 square feet of new retail and dining, and 2.5 acres of public green space. Targeting young professionals commuting between Boulder and Denver, it aims to offer urban-style amenities in a suburban setting, effectively creating a new "community hub" that the area previously lacked.
For local governments, these projects represent a significant economic driver and a strategic move to prevent commercial decline. The FlatIron Crossing mall is Broomfield's top sales tax generator, and city leaders were determined not to let it fall into disrepair. The collaboration between the city and the mall's ownership group, Macerich, was crucial. This public-private partnership ensured the redevelopment aligned with city goals, notably the inclusion of a 20% affordable housing component. This commitment addresses a critical community need that market-rate projects often overlook.
Despite the benefits, mall redevelopment is not without challenges. High construction costs and labor shortages can lead some developers to opt for complete demolition and rebuild, often resulting in luxury housing that does not meet broader affordability needs. The success of a project often hinges on early and continuous collaboration between developers and municipal officials. As Jacob Knudsen, Vice President at Macerich, stated, engaging the city "when we started thinking about what this project wanted to be" was essential, with housing being a "huge focus for them."
The conversion of malls into mixed-use communities is a pragmatic response to modern economic and housing realities. Key takeaways for communities considering similar projects include:









